Judge's Ruling Shakes Karen Read Murder Trial

Massachusetts Murder Trial Update: Judge Rules in Favor of Defense on Key Evidence The Karen Read murder trial in Massachusetts took a significant turn this morning, June 2nd, 2025, as the presiding judge ruled in favor of the defense regarding the admissibility of text messages from former Trooper Proctor. This decision, revealed in a short video clip from a live courtroom feed, could impact the prosecution's case substantially. The judge's statement, partially captured in the video, indicated that while the messages were authenticated, their potential for reflecting bias or omissions in the police investigation warranted a limiting instruction. "So I'll give a limiting instruction at the time they came in," the judge stated. This suggests a careful consideration of the evidence's potential prejudice. The trial centers around charges of murder, vehicular manslaughter, and leaving the scene of a collision causing death. The victim, John O'Keefe, was found dead outside the home of fellow Boston Police Officer Brian Albert. The defense's strategy likely hinges on challenging the integrity of the police investigation, and this evidentiary ruling appears to support that strategy. The impact of this ruling remains to be seen, but it is a clear turning point in the proceedings, underscoring the complexities of the case and the ongoing legal battles.