Broadway's Best: Tony Award Winners Share Their Top Picks for First-Timers

The 2025 Tony Awards red carpet buzzed with excitement, and Vanity Fair captured some of the most anticipated opinions from Broadway's biggest stars. The interviewer asked each celebrity for their recommendation for a first-time Broadway showgoer. Lea Michele, a Broadway veteran, enthusiastically declared, "If you've never seen a Broadway show, you have to go to Hamilton!" In contrast, Sadie Sink offered a more contemporary choice, suggesting Maybe Happy Ending. This diversity of opinions reflects the wide array of shows available. Daniel Dae Kim also recommended Maybe Happy Ending, sharing a heartwarming anecdote about his son's reaction to the play. Other suggestions included Just in Time, Purpose, Oh, Mary!, Floyd Collins, and Gypsy, representing a spectrum of styles and themes. The event highlighted the vibrancy and diversity of Broadway's offerings, promising a rich experience for newcomers and seasoned theatergoers alike.